NY Times Covers Google Mashups

John Musser, October 21st, 2005

SF Bart Map Thursday’s New York Times covered the maps-mashing phenomenon in an article entitled “A Journey to a Thousand Maps Begins With an Open Code”. The core of the story is not new to readers here but it does cover a number of interesting examples (most or all of which can be found at the excellent Google Maps Mania):

Perhaps the most notable part of the story is towards the end when discussing how Trulia, a for-profit business and not just a hobbyist site, is beginning to run into one of the core mashup issues: data ownership, royalties, and how to share revenue. As their business grows, Google has expressed an interest in sharing. And not that Realtors would try to control their data either…

Both comments and pings are currently closed.

6 Responses to “NY Times Covers Google Mashups”

October 21st, 2005
at 3:19 am
Comment by: Julian Bond

There’s an issue here that is raising it’s ugly head.

When an API is provided by a commercial company, to what extent should they be entitled to share in profits generated by a commercial company using it?

My gut feel is “None, No way”. If they want to share in the profits they can buy me. And/Or they should share *their* profits with me because I’ve made their service more valuable.

October 21st, 2005
at 5:52 am
Comment by: Mashable*

Google Maps Mashups and the Elusive Business Model

John Musser over at ProgrammableWeb (a great source for info on APIs, I might add!) has posted about the NY Times article* on Google Maps mashups. John has picked out some fairly cool mashups that are worth mentioning:

HomePriceRecords: Combines…

October 21st, 2005
at 7:31 am
Comment by: John

Julian, agreed that sometimes that may be true, but not so sure in all cases. And revenue/cost sharing can be a mutually-beneficial model, as in the case of eBay. They’ve successfully developed a model whereby developers pay for every API call they make, but, as long as the developer can leverage that to make more money than it costs them, ok. Not to say that perhaps eBay couldn’t make even more money if they charged nothing. That’s part of the give it away to grow the pie vs. take a bigger slice of the existing pie debate.

October 24th, 2005
at 10:16 pm
Comment by: John E

Hello, I have created a mashup of real-time seattle 911 data at http://www.seattle911.com. Let me know what you think.

Thanks

August 20th, 2006
at 10:45 pm
Comment by: Jeff

Google Map of New York City Red Light Cameras
http://www.photoenforced.com/ny.html

September 29th, 2006
at 2:35 pm
Comment by: Charles Verge

Web API’s are another service and there are many services in this world that are free and paid. I figure there will be all sorts of business models that will work depending on the API.

For now lots of businesses will offer free API access tell they have a good user base. Then companies will start charging when they can make money or they are forced to due to cost to run.

EDI is a example of an API that has been around for quite some time and many paying customers.

Follow the PW team on Twitter

ProgrammableWeb
APIs, mashups and code. Because the world's your programmable oyster.

John Musser
Founder, ProgrammableWeb

Adam DuVander
Executive Editor, ProgrammableWeb. Author, Map Scripting 101. Lover, APIs.